Only a few years ago, the Silent Hill name was considered a relic of the horror genre. Its best efforts were its earliest from 20 or more years ago, and it had since lost its way. Lately, though, it’s found its footing again, first with Bloober Team’s remarkable remake of Silent Hill 2 in 2024, then with 2025’s brilliantly rule-breaking Silent Hill f. Now, with Screen Burn’s Silent Hill: Townfall, the comeback feels complete. Townfall is the third memorable entry in as many years, reviving a legendary series for a new era.
Like Silent Hill f, Townfall defies tradition and takes the series outside the United States, this time to Scotland. There, an American man named Simon Ordell washes up on the shore of a blue-collar island town, St. Amelia. Right away, Townfall captures the all-important tone of a Silent Hill game. It’s more than the fog that’s become synonymous with the series: It’s the unsettling stillness, the sense of sadness lurking in every shop and down every alleyway that lingers like a harbinger of the dread that will certainly follow. Though it adheres to some of the series’ touchstones, it’s a fully standalone entry. It works just as well if this is your first Silent Hill game.
As you explore the town, it becomes clear early on that St. Amelia has suffered a tragedy so severe that the community was shuttered almost overnight. Heartfelt memorials in the town square dedicate pictures and words to loved ones taken too soon, and the displays are only matched in number and emotion by the many protest signs demanding accountability. The finer details, of course, aren’t yours to understand for a long while. Like the fog and its accompanying melancholy, Silent Hill also serves as the stage for startling truths that only emerge late in a character’s journey.
But if you think you know where it’s going, I bet you don’t. Screen Burn’s founder and Townfall’s writer Jon McKellan once ran a fansite dedicated to this series, and that sort of lifelong devotion is clear by the end of Townfall. He and his team understand what Silent Hill has been, but also–and more importantly–what it can be. The rules of this universe are played a bit fast and loose, and it’s better for it. Is Silent Hill a physical place, or an idea? Is everyone found there sent to suffer? While some themes re-emerge like somber notes on a mandolin, some of Townfall’s best parts are how it toys with expectations, twisting them into new shapes and sometimes rejecting them.
Townfall feels a lot like Silent Hill 2 early on. The original music, as great as it is in its own right, deliberately recalls the series’ heyday, and you’ll spend some early hours navigating through the roundabout corridors of a hospital and an apartment complex. But this is more than a “fan game” liberally reusing what’s worked before. Screen Burn makes it its own.
