They went from normal childhoods to almost attacking worshippers at mosques, synagogue

Fuelled by anger and a sense of existential threat, the two youth crossed the threshold from holding toxic thoughts to preparing to carry out attacks.

Indoctrinated in the belief that Muslims would one day become the majority in Singapore and impose syariah law on the city-state, Dylan decided to plan an attack on worshippers at Assyafaah Mosque in Sembawang and Yusof Ishak Mosque in Woodlands.

“I was very certain that I would do it, and there would only be two outcomes: I would do the attack and end up getting killed by the police, or I would be caught by the police (before that).

“I was very determined, and I planned to commit (the attack) on the anniversary of the Christchurch attacks, in March 2021,” he said.

He bought a tactical vest online, which he intended to adorn with right-wing extremist symbols and attach his phone to in order to live stream the attack, as Tarrant had done. He also planned to buy a machete on online marketplace Carousell.

Meanwhile, Farhan had decided he would carry out a knife attack at Maghain Aboth Synagogue in Waterloo Street, on a Saturday after Jewish congregational prayers.

He made at least two reconnaissance trips to the synagogue in 2019, and found a spot along the exterior wall of the compound from which to ambush victims when they exited.

His plan was to kill three Jewish males, under the assumption that they would have served NS in Israel and thereby carried out atrocities against Palestinians.

“I based this on videos I had watched online, that depicted male Israeli soldiers in their 20s and 30s attacking Palestinians,” he said.

Both youngsters’ activities, including their preparations at home, escaped their parents’ notice.

While Farhan intended to carry out his synagogue attack with a Smith and Wesson blade he bought in 2016 for scouting activities, he practised his techniques at home with a replica to avoid damaging the knife or hurting himself.

With guidance from an online video, he made a replica knife from a PVC pipe and used it to practise stabbing motions, usually when he was alone in the kitchen.

Dylan’s parents came across his tactical vest at home, but he convinced them that he had bought it for his photography activities.

ISD officials got wind of both teens’ activities and intervened before either could execute their plans. But the detentions left their families reeling at how they had missed the signs.

Farhan’s mother Latifa remembered that evening clearly. Her son had not returned home and was not answering her calls. The officers’ arrival at her door simply confirmed that something had gone very wrong.

His sister Sophia said her first reaction was anger and disbelief. “I initially thought that he might have been framed,” she said. “It was very difficult to accept that (his radicalisation) could be true.”

Both of them recalled Farhan raising the topic of Palestine on occasion, which they understood as sympathy for injustice and suffering and which they viewed as a natural reaction.

Dylan’s parents said their son’s arrest triggered many questions in their minds about what could have led to his radicalisation.

“We were deeply shocked and in disbelief when we learnt about (his) plans, and it was very difficult to understand how this could have happened with our son,” said his mother.

“I struggled to reconcile this information with the son I knew… I cried a lot, trying to make sense of the situation.”

Faced with evidence from ISD, denial slowly turned into acceptance for both families. For the youth, rehabilitation was a long journey that took years.

Dylan said the initial months in detention were difficult, and he struggled with loneliness, though he met frequently with his case officers, psychologists, religious counsellors, tutors and mentors.

The turning point was a counselling session with Ustaz Ahmad Saiful Rijal Hassan and Reverend Joachim Lee Tai Loong, both religious experts and ISD’s rehabilitation partners.

At that meeting, Ustaz Rijal clarified the role of syariah law in Singapore – that it primarily governs Muslims’ marriages, divorces and inheritance, and operates alongside the secular legal system.

“It made me better understand that the threat of Muslims one day imposing syariah law on every Singaporean was erroneous,” Dylan said, calling his previous view of syariah law “false and extreme”.

Dylan sat his N- and O-level exams during his detention, and did well. He was released from detention in January 2024 and subsequently given a restriction order. He is now pursuing his studies in a tertiary institution.

Former detainees whom ST spoke to said they also had access to authoritative books such as Refuting ISIS by influential Syrian Islamic scholar Muhammad al-Yaqoubi.

The book meticulously details how ISIS’ words and theological justifications – such as for bombing mosques of other sects of Muslims – showed the terrorist organisation to be similar to the Khawarij. This is an extremist, early Islamic sect known for its superficial religiosity, without having a deep understanding of Islam.

Books also occupied Farhan, alongside his new routine of yard exercises, religious counselling and psychological therapies.

“Slowly, I understood the reason for my detention and decided to fully cooperate with the officers in order to correct my thinking,” he said. “I also had time to reflect on my thoughts and actions.”

It would be two years of detention before he was assessed to have made good progress on his rehabilitation. He was released on a restriction order in March 2023.

ISD said that of the 19 radicalised youth dealt with under the ISA since 2015, five have had their restriction orders lapse. Apart from five who remain in detention, the rest are either gainfully employed or pursuing further studies, it added.

Both Dylan and Farhan said the weekly family visits were what helped them emerge from the darkness.

“They were my anchor and spurred me to keep trying in my rehabilitation, even as things were hard,” said Dylan.

Even as the rehabilitation process had deepened the relationship with their sons, the former detainees’ parents urged others to be more vigilant about their children’s online activities, and to pay attention even when no help is asked for.

“For parents who feel this could never happen in their own family, we would say that even having a strong family foundation does not mean it cannot happen,” said Dylan’s parents.

“The internet can be a double-edged sword, and can influence young people in ways families may not realise. It could happen to anyone, especially as many youths today spend a lot of time online.”

Latifa said: “Our advice to other family members is to stay observant and involved, so that early intervention can happen if needed.”